First conviction in Obamagate. Many more need to come.
Today was the first indictment by John Durham’s
investigation into the Obama administration and Deep State’s illegal spying on the
Trump campaign. An Obama-era FBI lawyer,
Kevin Clinesmith, hired by the FBI in July 2015, is expected to plead guilty to
a charge of making a false statement in connection with the FBI’s application
for a fourth FISA warrant to continue spying on Carter Page, a member of Trump’s
campaign team. Let me explain why this
is a BIG DEAL.
First, what did Kevin Clinesmith do? The context will be explained below, but Kevin
Clinesmith took an email he had received from the CIA that said Carter Page had
been a source of intelligence information for the CIA, doctored the email
from the CIA to say that Carter Page was “not a ‘source,’” and forwarded that
doctored email to a Supervisory Special Agent within the FBI in order to obtain
a FISA warrant to continue spying on Carter Page.
Second, who is Carter Page?
Carter Page is a former Navy officer and was affiliated with Trump’s campaign
as a foreign policy advisor in 2016. Carter
Page’s career had involved “ties” to Russia.
Duh. That’s what foreign policy
people do – talk to foreigners. In the foreign
policy business, foreign countries try to recruit Americans to turn traitor and
spy for them. Of course Russia does
this. Russia tried to recruit Carter
Page in 2013. However, Carter Page was
actually a CIA asset and reported to the CIA on Russian intelligence actions
against the United States between 2008 and 2013.
To spy on an American citizen, you must have probable cause
of a crime. See U.S. Constitution,
Fourth Amendment. Having no probable
cause Carter Page committed any crime, the Obama Administration alleged Carter
Page was suspected of being a traitorous spy working for Russia. That way, they could get a warrant from the “FISA”
court, i.e., “Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act,” to spy on Carter Page
and, hence, within the Trump campaign (i.e., tap his phones, bug his office,
use his cellphone with the cooperation of Google and Apple to record without
his knowledge, etc.).
You still need evidence to present to the FISA court,
the “FISC,” to support the government’s suspicion that Carter Page was a
Russian agent. Carter Page being a
foreign policy expert had, of course, been to Russia and talked with Russians. He did so in patriotic duty to the United States. Obama’s FBI spun these Russia contacts into
suspicion that Carter Page had turned traitor.
The FISA court is secret.
The suspect doesn’t get a say in whether a warrant issues. This imposes upon the government seeking a
FISA warrant a duty of complete candor to the FISC judge, to provide all material
information, including evidence that contradicts or exonerates the suspicion
that an American is a foreign agent.
Obama’s FBI knew that Carter Page was in fact a CIA source
providing the United States with intelligence on Russian agents working against
the United States. The CIA told Obama’s
FBI that Carter Page was in fact an American CIA source of intelligence in a
written memo in August 2016.
Nonetheless, Obama’s FBI sought a FISA warrant to authorize
spying on Carter Page in October 2016. The
FISA warrant application omitted the fact that Carter Page had worked for
the CIA, providing the CIA with intelligence against Russia, from
2008 to 2013. This fact would explain Carter Page's contacts with Russians as opposed to leaving the FISC judge with no other explanation. The FBI filed three more
FISA warrant applications seeking to continue spying on Carter Page, both
before and after Trump’s inauguration. None
of these FISA applications disclosed to the FISC judge that Carter Page was in
fact an American source providing intelligence to America against
Russia. Who signed these FISA applications? James Comey, Andrew McCabe, Sally Yates, Dana
Boente and Rod Rosenstein.
Now to today’s indictment.
Obama-era FBI lawyer Kevin Clinesmith was part of the process within the
FBI to obtain the fourth and final FISA warrant against Carter Page. By that time, June 2017, the Muller
Investigation was in full swing. Carter
Page had publicly announced that he had been an intelligence source for the
United States. This public announcement
caused the FBI to once again ask the CIA whether Carter Page had ever been a
CIA source.
Kevin Clinesmith’s supervisor, a so-called “Supervisory
Special Agent” (“SSA”) that the criminal information doesn’t name, asked him to
confirm with the CIA whether Carter Page had ever been an intelligence source
for the CIA. Kevin Clinesmith then emailed
the CIA and asked them. In this email, Kevin
Clinesmith acknowledged, “There is an indication that [Carter Page] may be a ‘[digraph]’
source. This is a fact we would need to
disclose in our next FISA renewal.” (A “digraph”
is a two-letter acronym the CIA uses to describe what type of intelligence
source a person is. The public criminal
information against Kevin Clinesmith doesn’t specify the two-letter acronym,
which is apparently super-secret CIA code.)
The CIA emailed Kevin Clinesmith back and said Carter Page was a former
CIA source, and referenced the earlier August 2016 memo the CIA had provided to
the FBI when it opened the “Crossfire Hurricane” investigation against the Trump
campaign.
Kevin Clinesmith then exchanged a series of text messages
with his SSA. In these texts, Kevin
Clinesmith said that the CIA confirmed Carter Page was merely a “subsource,” “was
never a source” and “CIA confirmed explicitly he was never a source.” The SSA asked whether Kevin Clinesmith got
that from the CIA in writing. Kevin
Clinesmith texted back that the CIA did put it in writing, and forwarded the
email he had received by the CIA to the SSA.
Kevin Clinesmith doctored that email. We all know that when you forward an email
using Outlook, you can edit the text of the email you are forwarding. Kevin Clinesmith inserted the words “and not
a ‘source’” into the CIA’s email to him, then forwarded that doctored email to the
SSA after falsely telling him the CIA had confirmed Carter Page was never a CIA
source. Because of this doctored email,
the FBI SSA believed the CIA had confirmed Carter Page was not an intelligence source
for the United States, despite his public pronouncements. Thus, the fourth and last FISA application seeking
an extension of the warrant to continue spying on Carter Page omitted the fact
that Carter Page had been a CIA source of foreign intelligence information
against Russia.
Who is Kevin Clinesmith?
A flat-out traitor. After Trump’s
election, he texted another FBI lawyer, Sally Moyer,
·
“I’m just devastated. I can’t wait until I can
leave today and just shut off the world for the next four days.”
·
“I just can’t imagine the systematic disassembly
of the progress we made over the last 8 years. ACA is gone. Who knows if the
rhetoric about deporting people, walls, and crap is true. I honestly feel like
there is going to be a lot more gun issues, too, the crazies won finally. This
is the tea party on steroids. And the GOP is going to be lost, they have to
deal with an incumbent in 4 years. We have to fight this again. Also Pence is
stupid.”
·
“Plus, my god damned name is all over the legal
documents investigating his staff.”
·
When asked by Moyer, “Is it making you rethink
your commitment to the Trump administration?” Kevin Clinesmith replied, “Hell
no.” and then added, “Viva le resistance.”
In sum, a traitorous Obama-era FBI lawyer intentionally
doctored an email he received from the CIA in order to continue illegally spying
on a member of Trump’s campaign team. He
is about to plead guilty to this heinous crime.
Yahoo! and CNN are not covering the story, but to their credit, MSNBC
and the New York Times do have this story on their front web pages.